When the economy wobbles, giving gets cautious. Across schools, nonprofits, and community groups, organizers are feeling the pressure mount. Donations are down, expenses are up, and the same volunteers are doing more with less. Sound familiar?
At Cheddar Up, we hear you. And we’re here to say: You’re not alone, you’re not crazy, and you’re definitely not imagining that fundraising feels harder than ever.
The State of Giving (Spoiler: It’s Complicated)
Recent reports show that while giving hasn’t disappeared, donor behavior is less predictable. People are still giving, but not as consistently, and not always in the ways organizers expect. Donations now hinge on emotional connection, clear impact, and a smooth giving experience.
This shift is affecting a wide range of groups, from high school sports teams and PTOs to booster clubs and community organizations. Our recent survey found that 95% of high school sports programs rely on fundraising to operate. Coaches often spend countless hours collecting payments, mining for sponsorships, and encouraging parent participation — all while handling their core responsibilities with limited support.
That same pressure shows up in schools. Just ask Summer Havron, a PTO leader at Whiteland Elementary. Her team was losing up to 50% of profits before switching to Cheddar Up.
If we hadn’t had that [Cheddar Up] option, I don’t know that we would have raised that much on our own through [other] digital platforms,” she said.
Now, they’re keeping every dollar and managing efforts from one place.
Groups like these need tools that streamline the work, build trust with donors, and make every dollar count. When the donor experience includes confusing checkouts, unexpected fees, or prompts to tip the platform, it can lead to hesitation and reduce future support.
How to Raise More, Even in Tough Times
Switching to a better platform is a great start, but real success comes from how you use it. Here’s how to get more from every ask, every time:
Get Laser-Focused on Your “Why”
People give to people and purposes, not just programs. Be crystal clear and emotionally compelling about what you’re raising money for. Then reinforce your message across your customizable collection page with banners, videos, and storytelling magic.
Make Giving Ridiculously Easy
No app downloads. No login walls. Just click and pay. Use Cheddar Up’s frictionless payment options and QR codes so supporters can give quickly and easily, whether they’re at an event, on their phone, or relaxing at home.
Expand Your Reach with Peer-to-Peer Fundraising
Difficult times call for a wide reach. Enable peer-to-peer fundraising so supporters can share your mission with their networks. Give them templates, talking points, and some digital pom-poms.
Stay in Touch with Your Supporters
Good communication goes a long way. Send updates, say thank you, and let people know how their gift is making a difference. With automated receipts and easy follow-up tools, Cheddar Up helps you keep donors in the loop and feel appreciated without adding more to your responsibilities.
Show the Numbers
Activate fundraising goal tracking so donors can see the needle move. People are more likely to give when they feel their contribution will actually help you reach your goal.
Keep Checkout Clear and Trustworthy
“Tipping” shouldn’t be part of the donation experience, especially when it’s not for the cause. Yet many platforms ask donors to leave a “tip” for the platform itself, creating confusion and frustration that can derail giving. Cheddar Up takes a stand against this. No tipping prompts. No murky add-ons. Just a clean, transparent checkout.
Offer Fee Clarity and Options
When every dollar counts, transparency matters. Let donors know they have the option to cover processing fees, and consider enabling lower-cost eCheck payments available with Pro and Team Plans to keep more funds in your community.
Let’s Weather This Together
If your community is feeling the fundraising fatigue, we get it. More importantly, we can help. Join the thousands of groups using Cheddar Up to create better, simpler fundraising experiences.
Because your mission matters. And the tools you use to support it should work just as hard as you do.
Before you go
We know fundraising isn’t always easy, especially right now. That’s why Cheddar Up gives you the tools to build donor trust and raise more money with less friction, even when times are tough.
You may also like:
Booked Authors streamlines school book sales with Cheddar Up
As Executive Director of Booked Authors, Allyson Hickey oversees school book sales tied to author visits across the country. Many of those sales happen at the same time, often with tight timelines and high expectations from schools, PTAs, and families.
For years, the process relied on paper order forms sent home in backpacks, checks returned on uneven schedules, and handwritten personalization details that were not always easy to read. Tracking orders required follow-up, and even small errors created extra work during already busy seasons.
As school book sales grew in volume, the cracks became harder to ignore. Managing multiple author visits and book orders at once left little room for inefficiency. Allyson knew the process needed to support growth without adding more manual work.
How to run a PTA holiday shop (plus a free volunteer template)
The PTA holiday shop is one of those feel-good school traditions that brings smiles and a little seasonal sparkle. Kids pick out gifts for their families on their own, and your school raises money and builds community spirit. As the PTA member running it, you’ll have to make a lot of decisions, like who supplies the inventory, what to price at $1 versus $5, how many volunteers each shift needs, and how kids pay at the register.
This guide walks you through everything you’ll need to host a successful PTA holiday shop, from eight weeks out to cleanup day. You’ll also find a free online volunteer sign up template you can customize and share with your school community. A PTA holiday shop is a pop-up store your parent group runs at school, where students buy small, low-priced gifts for family and friends. Volunteers help kids shop and wrap, and the PTA keeps the proceeds for school programs.
The Best Giving Tuesday Campaigns: A Guide to Success
Giving Tuesday has quickly grown into the world’s largest day of giving. Since its start in 2012, it has spread to over 100 countries, inspiring billions in donations every year. For nonprofits, schools, and community groups, it’s a powerful chance to rally supporters and meet ambitious goals. But not all campaigns achieve the same results. Some stand out, raising impressive amounts and energizing their communities. So, what separates the best Giving Tuesday campaigns from the rest? Let’s break down the traits of successful campaigns and how you can apply them to your own efforts.
Holiday Wreath Fundraiser Tips for Merry Success
A holiday wreath fundraiser is a festive, low-risk way for schools, PTAs, sports teams, and nonprofits to raise money during the winter season. With a little planning and the right online fundraising platform, you can turn a wreath sale into a joyful, community-powered fundraising success.
This guide covers the full Christmas wreath sale, from picking products and a supplier to running pickup day, plus how to add Christmas trees to the same sale without setting up a tree lot.
Ready to set things up now? Start with the holiday wreath fundraiser template and add your own products and prices.
The best Christmas wreath fundraising ideas give supporters a few clear choices at different price points. A classic wreath covers most buyers, and one or two upgraded options bring in larger orders from those who want a more elaborate wreath.
