Givebacks PTA Alternative: The Right Choice for Your Group
Managing payments, fundraising, and signups for your group shouldn’t require multiple tools or extra hassle. Platforms like Givebacks and Cheddar Up both aim to simplify the process, but the experience, flexibility, and cost can look very different depending on your needs.
Cheddar Up
A flexible, easy-to-use platform built for all types of groups. Manage payments, signups, fundraising, and sales in one place, without any extra tools or complicated setup required.
Givebacks (formerly Memberhub)
A platform focused on PTAs and schools, offering fundraising and cashback-style giving programs. Some management features may involve additional steps, tools, or fees.
Want to see how Cheddar Up can work for you? Check out our template library for customizable options that fit your needs!
Compare Features: Cheddar Up vs. Givebacks
When choosing a platform for your group’s payments, signups, and management, it’s important to know which features matter most. Cheddar Up delivers unmatched versatility with tools that cater to all types of groups and activities. Here’s how they stack up:
Create branded pages for school fundraisers with images, banners, and custom messaging.
Sell school merchandise, track inventory, and offer shipping options directly from your PTA page.
Accept payments during PTA events using mobile apps and card readers.
Easily organize volunteer schedules for school events, fundraisers, or classroom activities without needing to collect payments.
Consolidate all active fundraisers (like bake sales, auctions, or spirit wear)in one place for parents.
Automate monthly or annual PTA membership dues for hassle-free collection.
Easily collect digital waivers for events, trips, or activities, ensuring compliance and convenience.
Transactions are seamlessly sent from your collection to MoneyMinder for easy accounting
Cheddar Up vs. Givebacks: Clear & Transparent Fees
Cheddar Up keeps fees simple and organizer-friendly, letting you decide who covers transaction costs.
Organizer can choose to absorb fees or give payer the option to cover fees.
Pricing is consistent across all campaigns.
Basic Plan: 3.95% + $0.95
Pro Plan: 3.59% + $0.59
Team Plan: 3.59% + $0.59
Pro Plan: 1.59% (min $1)
Team Plan: Flat $0.95
Free (and tracked!)
Organizer can choose to absorb fees or give payer the option to cover fees
Pricing varies across campaigns and credit card types.
Store Items: 3.95% + $0.95
Direct Donations: Amex: 2.99% + $0.49
Other Cards: 1.99% + $0.49
Campaigns - Tip Model Pricing:
Pricing: Amex: 3.5% + $0.50
Other Cards: 2.9% + $0.30
Campaigns - Percent Pricing:
Platform Fee: 7.5%
Amex: 3.5% + $0.50
Other Cards: 2.9% + $0.30
Not Supported
Manual tracking supported
*Fees shown as of 4/2026. Please confirm with other vendors’ fees in case of changes or increases.
Skip the Tip
Cheddar Up’s pricing is simple and transparent, designed to give you and your donor confidence every step of the way. Instead of relying on donor “tips” to fund operations, which creates confusion about where the money is going, Cheddar Up keeps everything clear.
Donors know their contributions go directly to your cause, and organizers have the flexibility to decide how to handle fees: pass them along or cover them. With Cheddar Up, there are no surprises, just straightforward, flexible options that put you in control.
You’re in good company
Each month, Cheddar Up serves thousands of groups and communities across the US, helping them collect millions of dollars in payments (plus information) for just about anything. But don’t take our word for it, check out Cheddar Up reviews from our users.
CSA
6TH Grade Parents’ Committee 22
Why Organizers Choose Cheddar Up vs Givebacks
AUTOMATIC TRACKING
FRICTION-FREE PAYMENTS
PAYMENTS + INFO
CUSTOM PAYMENT PAGES
INTEGRATED POINT OF SALE
EASY HANDOFF
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Givebacks offer sign-ups and forms?
Yes, Givebacks includes forms and sign-up functionality for activities like events, memberships, and fundraising. These tools are typically tied to specific campaigns rather than designed to be used flexibly across different types of collections with or without payment.
Is Givebacks easy to use for PTAs and schools?
Givebacks offers a range of tools, but some organizers report that the platform can feel less intuitive to navigate. Managing different activities may involve multiple steps or workflows, which can make the overall experience feel more complex for busy PTA volunteers.
Can PTAs manage everything in one place with Givebacks?
Givebacks includes tools for fundraising, memberships, and events, but these are often managed through separate workflows. As a result, some groups find it harder to run all their activities from a single, centralized experience.
How does Givebacks pricing work?
Givebacks uses a combination of platform fees and payment processing fees that vary depending on the type of transaction, such as store purchases, donations, or fundraising campaigns. Organizations can choose between different pricing models depending on how they collect funds.
Are there downsides to Givebacks’ pricing model?
Givebacks uses different pricing structures for stores, donations, and campaigns, which can be a bit confusing for organizers and payers. This can make the overall fee structure feel less straightforward compared to platforms with a consistent approach.
How does Givebacks compare to Cheddar Up?
Givebacks and Cheddar Up both help groups collect money and run fundraisers, but they’re built for different needs. Givebacks focuses on school-based fundraising programs, while Cheddar Up offers a more flexible, all-in-one way to manage payments, signups, and fundraising in one place.
What are Givebacks reviews like?
Recent user feedback highlights challenges with usability, including navigation and completing tasks across different parts of the platform. Some users also mention confusion around fees and checkout experiences.
Ready to start?
Have questions? Chat on demand, or email — we’ve got you covered.
Kick the tires
Create a free account and build a collection to see how easy it is to collect money.
